to top 10 table

10 Best Bike Saddles Reviewed & Compared

last updated Nov 10, 2018
The saddle is an essential part of a bicycle since it’s what most of the weight is supported by, and is also where a sensitive and important part of your body meets a rapidly moving piece of sporting equipment. Having the wrong seat can lead to discomfort and may also negatively affect your overall cycling performance.

Different people and riding styles place different demands on a bike seat, so just because one seat works for one rider doesn’t mean it’s going to work for you. In order to pick the right one, make sure to consider the core attributes, weight and padding, as well as your body type and how much comfort the seat will give you.

Scroll down below and read our list of the top 10 best bike saddles currently available, and your behind will thank you.
Researched Sources
8
Researched Sources
Reviews Considered
1200
Reviews Considered
Hours Researching
12
Hours Researching
Products Evaluated
10
Products Evaluated
Last Updated:
Avatar
By Giselle Killebrew:

We have replaced a couple of previous recommendations with highly recommended options that many cyclists highly recommend. Make sure to take a look at other sections on our page to learn how we make our decisions and what to look for before making your purchase.

Sorting Options
Materials Comfort Stability Weight Value By Default
Rank
PictureProduct
Name
Rating
Shops
1
The rating is based on the average rating (1-100) from all the criteria in which we rated this product.
91.8
Materials
99%
Comfort
90%
Stability
90%
Weight
90%
Value
90%
Price Comparison Last Updated (15.11.18)
$99.99
2
The rating is based on the average rating (1-100) from all the criteria in which we rated this product.
89
Materials
85%
Comfort
88%
Stability
89%
Weight
90%
Value
93%
Price Comparison Last Updated (15.11.18)
$45.20
3
The rating is based on the average rating (1-100) from all the criteria in which we rated this product.
88.2
Materials
87%
Comfort
83%
Stability
91%
Weight
90%
Value
90%
Price Comparison Last Updated (15.11.18)
$28.50
4
The rating is based on the average rating (1-100) from all the criteria in which we rated this product.
85.8
Materials
95%
Comfort
82%
Stability
82%
Weight
85%
Value
85%
Price Comparison Last Updated (15.11.18)
$101.06
5
The rating is based on the average rating (1-100) from all the criteria in which we rated this product.
83.8
Materials
91%
Comfort
85%
Stability
85%
Weight
70%
Value
88%
Price Comparison Last Updated (15.11.18)
$35.95
6
The rating is based on the average rating (1-100) from all the criteria in which we rated this product.
80.8
Materials
90%
Comfort
84%
Stability
85%
Weight
70%
Value
75%
Price Comparison Last Updated (15.11.18)
$120.00
Best Deal
$140.39
7
The rating is based on the average rating (1-100) from all the criteria in which we rated this product.
78.4
Materials
91%
Comfort
70%
Stability
72%
Weight
90%
Value
69%
Price Comparison Last Updated (15.11.18)
$118.93
Best Deal
$127.49
$131.57
Best Deal
8
The rating is based on the average rating (1-100) from all the criteria in which we rated this product.
76.6
Materials
80%
Comfort
80%
Stability
65%
Weight
88%
Value
70%
Price Comparison Last Updated (15.11.18)
$99.30
$113.17
Best Deal
9
The rating is based on the average rating (1-100) from all the criteria in which we rated this product.
74
Materials
55%
Comfort
84%
Stability
81%
Weight
65%
Value
85%
Price Comparison Last Updated (15.11.18)
$15.89
10
The rating is based on the average rating (1-100) from all the criteria in which we rated this product.
72.4
Materials
60%
Comfort
85%
Stability
60%
Weight
73%
Value
84%
Price Comparison Last Updated (15.11.18)
$10.99
In Depth Review Top 10
  • Fabric Line Race
  • Selle Royal Respiro
  • Planet Relief Saddle
  • Fizik Arione
  • WTB Speed Comp
  • Brooks England
  • Fabric Scoop Pro
  • Ergon SME3 Pro
  • Outerdo
  • Zacro Gel
Table of contents
  • Criteria Used for Evaluation
  • Other Factors to Consider
  • Frequently Asked Questions
  • Sources

Top 10 Picks

1. Fabric Line Race

The rating is based on the average rating (1-100) from all the criteria in which we rated this product.
91.8
Fabric Line Race
Materials
99
Comfort
90
Stability
90
Weight
90
Value
90
best offer for today
$99.99
Pros:

Durable

Waterproof cover

Pressure release channel

PU foam

Lightweight

Allows for full range of motion

Cons:

Pricey

Not suitable if you need a wide seat

The Fabric Line Race seat is a great waterproof option that also provides just the right amount of cushioning you need during your rides.

Read more

Material
The rails of this seat are made of titanium alloy, the shell uses PU foam, and the cover is made of waterproof microfiber material.

Shape
This is a slim model that is lightweight and better for those of you looking to improve their speed.

Padding
It features a blend of cushioning for sufficient padding to increase comfort and reduce fatigue and provide shock absorption.

Weight
At 13.4 ounces this model is pretty lightweight but definitely not the most lightweight option out there.

2. Selle Royal Respiro

The rating is based on the average rating (1-100) from all the criteria in which we rated this product.
89
Selle Royal Respiro
Materials
85
Comfort
88
Stability
89
Weight
90
Value
93
best offer for today
$45.20
Pros:

Great price

Comfortable

Lightweight

Breathable

Active ventilation system

Cons:

Narrow fit

Lightweight but not built for speed

It is specifically made for women and is extremely lightweight, comfortable, and flexible. It has several color options and features a sleek design.

Read more

Material
This one is made of highly breathable and lightweight materials that will keep you cool and dry during your rides.

Shape
It features a slim fit, but not as slim as those built specifically for speed.

Padding
As far as padding, this one provides you with the necessary amount but nothing more. It also has an active ventilation system for maximum breathability and does a good job of putting what padding there is in the right places.

Weight
This one isn't super lightweight, but it won't weigh you down either.

3. Planet Relief Saddle

The rating is based on the average rating (1-100) from all the criteria in which we rated this product.
88.2
Planet Relief Saddle
Materials
87
Comfort
83
Stability
91
Weight
90
Value
90
best offer for today
$28.50
Pros:

Anatomically designed to accommodate men's bodies

Pressure relief cut out

Well-padded

Supportive

Covering feels soft against the skin

Cons:

Padding issues for some reviewers (too hard/too soft)

A popular option with a pressure relieving cut out and an affordable price tag. The cover feels nice against the skin and the padding is comfortable yet supportive. It comes in three design options and is a made to fit a man's body.

Read more

Material
The soft material covering the seat is gentle on the skin. It's also resistant to tearing.

Shape
The shape is meant to accommodate a man's body and features a groove to support and relieve pressure on the male anatomy.

Padding
SuperSoft padding is used to ensure the rider is comfortable sitting. Some users did mention that they would have preferred the seat to be a bit softer. Still, the seat provides a supportive ride to cyclists.

Weight
It is fairly lightweight but all types of riders found it made their ride more comfortable. When it comes to road biking, it's a particularly great option for indoor training throughout the winter months.

4. Fizik Arione

The rating is based on the average rating (1-100) from all the criteria in which we rated this product.
85.8
Fizik Arione
Materials
95
Comfort
82
Stability
82
Weight
85
Value
85
best offer for today
$101.06
Pros:

Very flexible

Durable, with a carbon reinforced nylon shell

Firm but still comfortable

Good for long rides

Cons:

A little heavy for some tastes

The Fizik Arione R5 K:ium is best situated for those who are more keen on road biking then other forms of cycling. Specially designed for long distance road riding and with the riders comfort in mind, built to ease the pain of long stints in the same position.

Read more

Material
The Fizik Arione R5 K:ium is made from a carbon reinforced nylon so that the seat is both comfortable but also sturdy, the carbon contributing to the seats noteworthy durability.

Shape:
This Fizik seat is long and thin with flexible edges to allow it to conform to the riders motions without restricting the riders' legs and thighs. The main length is also flexible to make any motion while cycling easier on the body of the rider. It is very thin, though, and would be difficult for a heavier rider to use.

Padding
The Fizik Arione R5 K:ium is best suited for long distance riding, the padding of it being firm but forgiving so that the rider is comfortable and not sore after cycling for long distances.

Weight:
The Arione R5 K:ium weighs 205 grams, or just under half a pound, and is considered a bit heavy and is one of the heavier seats in the Fizik line.

5. WTB Speed Comp

The rating is based on the average rating (1-100) from all the criteria in which we rated this product.
83.8
WTB Speed Comp
Materials
91
Comfort
85
Stability
85
Weight
70
Value
88
best offer for today
$35.95
Pros:

Well-padded

Durable covering

Great price

Supportive

Cons:

Heavier than some expected

This bicycle seat is made for fast riding. It's lightweight, won't break the bank, and will stand up to the test of time.

Read more

Material
It is made with quality materials that won't break down easily. Reviewers felt they got plenty of value for their money.

Shape
Reviewers liked the shape which is appropriate for distance riding and most other types of biking. A cut out helps eliminate pressure points.

Padding
It is padded but there's also plenty of firm support for riders who need it. Reviewers found the seat quite comfortable. It's suitable for long rides. It's rigid feeling but there's plenty of cushioning to pad your butt during a ride.

Weight
It weighs about 370 grams. It's not the lightest option out there but it's certainly a contender but reviewers felt that it delivered value and comfort and the extra weight wasn't such a big deal.

6. Brooks England

The rating is based on the average rating (1-100) from all the criteria in which we rated this product.
80.8
Brooks England
Materials
90
Comfort
84
Stability
85
Weight
70
Value
75
best offer for today
more shops
$140.39
$120.00
Best deal
Pros:

Very attractive design

Comfortable

Long-lasting

Molds to the body

Does not catch on clothing

Cons:

Non-adjustable

Heavy

This retro looking seat is the perfect option for the aesthetically driven rider. The seat comes in three style choices and is sure to make you look great while you ride. The handmade seat is made of quality leather and has been sold for over a century to style-oriented cyclists.

Read more

Material
It is made of high-quality leather using traditional methods. The rails are constructed using copper. Because leather is porous, it will allow the rider's butt to breathe even when it's hot and clammy out. To ensure this product lasts a long time it's important to give it a bit more care than other products considering its handmade leather construction.

Shape
The shape is meant to accommodate riders going the distance or those taking their bicycle to the trails.

Padding
The stiff seat is composed of padding that molds to your posterior. It's supportive but forgiving. Reviewers liked that it conformed to their bodies.

Weight
It is not appropriate for road cyclists who are looking to lighten the weight of their setup. It's a bit heavier than other models but it's super comfortable and durable.

7. Fabric Scoop Pro

The rating is based on the average rating (1-100) from all the criteria in which we rated this product.
78.4
Fabric Scoop Pro
Materials
91
Comfort
70
Stability
72
Weight
90
Value
69
best offer for today
more shops
$127.49
$118.93
Best deal
$131.57
Best deal
Pros:

Comfortable

No break-in needed

Flexible

Carbon fiber rails

Cons:

Pricey

The Fabric Scoop Pro is a thin tight piece of equipment for the invested cyclist. Its compact design helpful for promoting posture but doesn’t take away from the riders comfort.

Read more

Material
It is constructed from a shell of nylon and padded with PU foam for comfort. The rails are constructed from carbon fiber, which means the seat will be incredibly strong as well as lightweight.

Shape
The Fabric Scoop Pro is a thin and long shape, designed such so that a rider can easily position themselves properly. In turn, it would be more difficult for a heavier rider to sit comfortably on the Scoop Pro, since it is so thin, but on the other hand very few riders report any discomfort. The Scoop Pro is also very flexible and accommodating to different riding styles.

Padding
This seat is efficiently padded for comfort. Most report the Fabric Scoop Pro as being comfortable with little to no break in time after first installation and use.

Weight
The Fabric Scoop Pro is made, through shape and material, to be extremely lightweight.

8. Ergon SME3 Pro

The rating is based on the average rating (1-100) from all the criteria in which we rated this product.
76.6
Ergon SME3 Pro
Materials
80
Comfort
80
Stability
65
Weight
88
Value
70
best offer for today
more shops
$99.30
$113.17
Best deal
Pros:

Comfortable

Lightweight

Designed not to snag clothing

No uncomfortable designed aspects

Materials allow for ease of movement

Cons:

A little firm for some

Ergon’s SME3 Pro is a piece of bike gear ultimately designed with the ease of the rider in mind. So, if you are interested in a seat that you won’t have to give a second thought to while riding, then the SME3 Pro is likely the right one for you.

Read more

Material
The Ergon SME3 Pro is made with a carbon shell which contributes to the lightweight build. The carbon is also designed to be extremely flexible which allows for easy motion with and around the seat.

Shape
The shape of the SME3 Pro allows for a more diverse unrestricted range of motion without any sort of discomfort. Many of the users also say that had little to no issues with their clothes snagging due to this product's specific design. As it is a little wider, it should be able to accommodate a heavier rider more comfortably.

Padding
The padding is both comfortable and evenly distributed, riders reporting little to no discomfort in regard to the padding placement.

Weight
The SME3 Pro is constructed from carbon in order to ensure that it is lightweight.

9. Outerdo

The rating is based on the average rating (1-100) from all the criteria in which we rated this product.
74
Outerdo
Materials
55
Comfort
84
Stability
81
Weight
65
Value
85
best offer for today
$15.89
Pros:

Wicks moisture very well

Great air circulation

Well-padded with foam

Great for long rides

Excellent shock absorption

Budget price

Cons:

Heavy

Some concerns about durability

This elongated seat is offered in plenty of attractive color options. It features a cut out for pressure relief, a breathable covering, and comfortable foam padding. It's a great choice for both road bicycle riders or mountain bikers who want a supportive, good looking option.

Read more

Material
Made of a leathery type of covering it is super durable. It won't easily rip apart and is able to wick moisture effectively. One reviewer did complain about tearing occurring but they were in the minority.

Shape
It has an elongated shape and a hollow cut out to ensure pressure relief. The cut out also helps with ventilation. The slim shape also ensures that chafing doesn't occur.

Padding
The padding is made up of foam material. It's super comfortable and ensures riders' bottoms can handle long rides. Some reviewers expected more padding but were surprised by how much they enjoyed riding with this seat.

Weight
It's a lightweight option but not the lightest you can get. It's suggested use is with mountain bicycles which don't necessarily require super lightweight components. A few reviewers actually found the seat was lighter than they expected.

10. Zacro Gel

The rating is based on the average rating (1-100) from all the criteria in which we rated this product.
72.4
Zacro Gel
Materials
60
Comfort
85
Stability
60
Weight
73
Value
84
best offer for today
$10.99
Pros:

Budget price

Comfortable gel padding

Comes with a protective cover

Quality design for the price

Cons:

Some users had issues with adjustment

This bicycle seat comes with a special cover to protect it for when you need to lock up your bicycle as you head into work or school. It's an extremely affordable option that's great for all types of cycles. The well-padded seat will help ensure riding remains a comfortable experience.

Read more

Material
It is made of a soft covering for added comfort. It also comes with a handy seat cover to protect the seat from the elements and dirt. The material is meant to withstand repeated use. Reviewers felt that they were getting a good quality option.

Shape
A wider shape makes this a great option for riders who need a bit more impact protection as they cycle. It's a great choice for riders who want a comfort type seat for their commute.

Padding
Gel padding protects riders from the impact of riding. It's super well cushioned and riders love how well it protected them from bumps in the road. It makes riding a lot more comfortable. The padding does tend to compress after a while but at such a low price, this really isn't a big deal.

Weight
It's not the lightest out there but it's still suitable for really any kind of riding or biking.

Criteria Used for Evaluation

Materials

The type of materials the seat is made from makes a huge difference obviously in the performance of the seat, in everything from the comfort, to the fit and performance. One of the most important materials is the seat covering. Is the material soft or itchy? Does it cause chafing? Is it high-quality? We looked for models with coverings that reduced the potential for chafing, felt nice against bare skin, and were not prone to ripping or tearing. A durable covering will ensure you get the most value and use out of your product.

Comfort

Padding in a bike seat is what provides comfort to the rider. But it’s not as simple as just that. A generously padded seat doesn’t necessarily translate to a comfortable ride experience. Some riders prefer firmer cushioning and others will choose softer padding. That’s entirely up to you. Different types of padding materials will feel different, but it’s largely an individual preference. The options we chose to feature on this list all have some degree of cushioning and we selected models that deliver on their unique promises.

Stability

What kind of cycling will you be doing? What is your riding position? Riders who want to go fast will want a seat that features a slimmer profile so they can easily assume an aerodynamic riding position. For leisurely riders, a wider seat will ensure that upright riding feels comfortable. Pay attention to whether a particular seat is made for men or women or is unisex, too. Bicycle seats with cutouts can help reduce the amount of pressure put on the body during a ride and also help with breathability.

The position you're in when you ride your bicycle does a lot to determine what type of seat you will want, and how wide you will want it to be. And of course the wider something is the more stability it has.

Planning on going fast? Just taking a cruise? Going mountain biking? All of these things matter in addition to the type of bike, the type and position of the handlebars and even the seat height will determine whether or not you want a wide or narrow saddle. Generally narrow saddles are best for road cycling, wider seats are usually used more for pleasure cruising, and mountain biking seats tend to fall somewhere in the middle.

Upright riders should opt for a wider seat with lots of padding. Since your body is upright, in this position you’ll be putting a lot of pressure on your backside. A generous amount of cushioning will help to ensure that rides in this position don’t fatigue your butt too much.

If you’re planning on riding a bit faster with a slight lean in your body then opt for a sport-type model. These are less wide, have a good amount of padding (but not too much) and these often feature grooves or cutouts for pressure relief.

If you need an option for racing, you’ll want the lightest option out there since you won’t want to weigh down your ride. These seats don’t have as much padding but they should still be comfortable for your body type. You'll also want to pay attention to whether a particular seat is made for men or women or is unisex, too. Bicycle seats with cutouts can help reduce the amount of pressure put on the body during a ride and also help with breathability.

Weight

Weight is extra important if you’re interested in road racing since sticking a clunky seat on a carbon fiber bicycle is kind of counterproductive, but also makes a difference no matter what type of rider you are.. If you’re looking to race go with the lightest option you can find. Some riders will end up choosing slightly heavier options and sacrifice overall weight to add a bit more comfort to their backside on their ride.

Value

You don’t need to spend a lot of money to get yourself a quality product, and all of the saddles on our list offer the consumer a good value for their money, some more than others. Extremely lightweight models will cost more since they tend to be made with space age materials such as kevlar and carbon fiber, as will vintage-looking seats made of leather, but otherwise, it’s all about what feels comfortable while you ride. It's just not worth it to save a couple bucks only to be miserable during and after your ride, and not be able to enjoy such a wonderful activity.

Other Factors to Consider

Style

Hey, let’s not forget the look! It’s not going to make your ride more comfortable or enjoyable but there’s nothing wrong with opting for an option because it looks nice and makes your two-wheeled ride look super cool. Comfort and proper fit should be your primary considerations, but it’s okay to want to match your seat to your bicycle. A retro-looking comfort cruiser might benefit from having a sleek looking brown leather seat while a road bicycle might look a little weird with a big wide comfort model. If you need some styling tips, head over to Google image search for some inspiration.

Overall Fit

It’s not just about riding position and matching your seat to the type of riding you’ll be doing. Your body isn’t the same as any elses body. What works for you may not work for another and vice versa. And, newsflash, your butt may be wider or narrower than someone else’s. How can you tell if a model fits correctly? Sit on the model you’re considering and make sure it supports your sit bones.

Once you’ve found the right seat for your bum, made sure it fits right, has the padding you want, and is the correct shape for the type of riding you intend to do. Great!

So what's next? You need to make sure your seat is properly affixed to your bicycle. An improperly fitted seat can cause discomfort so make sure you have it on correctly. It should be at the correct height for your body and some riders may need to adjust the angle. If you’re unsure of the proper fit, just head over to a bicycle shop and get some help there.

Keep in mind, if you still feel uncomfortable with a correctly fitted seat that’s been properly affixed, it might be you that’s the problem. Make sure you’re positioning yourself correctly when you ride. A few other things that might help alleviate butt numbness are a bicycle with a good suspension. if you’re not interested in swapping bicycles, choose a seat that comes with built-in suspension.

Model

Ladies, don’t settle for any old model. Opt for models that are specifically tailored to a woman’s body. A woman’s option is designed to be able to accommodate the unique mix of a smaller frame with wide hips.

A final factor to think about is gel vs. foam seats. These are the two most common types of cushioning found in bicycle seats. Gel is the softest of the two and is a great choice for leisurely rides. It’s less durable, though. Foam is able to bounce back after being compressed and is more supportive.

Frequently Asked Questions

q: Why does it matter what kind of bike saddle I get?
a:

The wrong seat will impede your full range of motion and your ability to perform. It will also cause discomfort and possibly even unwanted aches, pains, and long-lasting soreness, which it’s why it’s important to consider your specific needs before making your purchase.

q: Does more cushioning mean a more comfortable ride?
a:

Not necessarily! Sometimes too much cushioning can reduce the amount of support you receive. Just like a pair of running shoes, you want some cushioning to dampen your impact but you should also receive the stability and support you need as well.

q: What’s the advantage of a wide bicycle saddle?
a:

A wider option allows for additional sitting positions while you're riding and provides more comfort for heavier or wider riders.

q: What are the advantages of a leather saddle?
a:

Leather-made models don’t just look good, they are also much more breathable than seats made from other materials.

q: Should I try before I buy?
a:

If possible absolutely. The same model will feel different depending on the rider. Don’t just settle on an option because it works for someone else, try it for yourself to find out for sure.

Sources

  1. Duncan Moore, Buyer’s guide: saddles, UK Cycling Specific Website, May 01, 2015
  2. Molly Hurford, Don't Make These Saddle-Buying Mistakes, Bicycling Magazine, Jul 19, 2015