Hoka One One Mafate Speed

7.5
7.5 score
Runnerclick score (7.5)/10

Our overall Runnerclick score is based on 3 different factors: Editor's rating after in-depth testing. User ratings submitted on this page Overall score from the "reviewmeter" based on reviews across the web the weight of each factor is: 40% editor rating 15% user ratings 45% reviewmeter
0
Editor rating: 7.0 / 10
User's rating: based on 1 user ratings
1 star
0%
2 star
0%
3 star
100%
4 star
0%
5 star
0%
Add your Rating
All Hoka One One Shoes
Hoka One One Mafate Speed Review Facts

Hoka One One has become a household name amongst runners due to the company’s reputation for generously-soled shoes which provide the support necessary for endurance, as well as speed. The Hoka One One Mafate Speed is no exception.  Exceptionally constructed, it’s advertised as a durable trail shoe that maximizes performance on technical trails. It is a lightweight, flexible running selection that holds up well for endurance runners. Users have found that it offers protection from mild to technical terrain, with an excellent blend of speed and stability. However, on rougher surfaces, many who are looking for a more comfortable feel and better midsole/upper shoe grip have found that the Hoka One One Mafate Speed may leave much to be desired.

Editor's Pros & Cons
Pros
  • Speed without backsplash
  • Excellent Support
  • Traction
  • Thick, efficient midsole
  • Durability
Cons
  • Stiff heel cup
  • Instability off the trail
  • Inconsistent tongue covering
See How
Reviews were analyzed here:
We read, analyze and sort reviews into positive & negative categories to give you the complete picture.
What are buyers saying?

We have spent 2 hours analyzing a total of 155 reviews.

These reviews are then categoried into "Positive" and "Negative" feedback.

Below you will read a summary of them:

Positive
  • Buyers praise the Mafate Speed as a great shoe for tough trail and pavement running.
  • They provide a good level of protection from sharp rocks and roots along with cushioning to keep your feet comfortable even on pavement.
  • Reviewers say these have worked well for them on a variety of terrain. From grass to pavement to rocky trails, most buyers say the Mafate Speed perform well.
  • Some reviewers say that these shoes also keep their feet comfortable during long work days in a hospital.
  • These shoes have great grip that can keep you feeling secure even on wet turf.
  • The shape of Mafate Speeds works well with long, narrow feet. The overall design is slightly more narrow than the original Mafate.
  • A large percentage of reviewers say these are their first choice for long distance running and training.
  • The upper is breathable.
  • According to reviewers, the material used is water resistant, drys fast.,and can drain water well.
  • The cushion in the insole helps to reduce pain from impact. One reviewer even claimed these helped him start running again after having foot surgery.
  • The design takes pressure off of the heels and ankles.
  • Most reviewers say they feel stable in Mafate Speeds.
  • The structure of these shoes holds the foot in place for secure footing during lateral movement.
  • Compared to other Hoka shoes, Mafate Speeds have good medial support.
  • The extra loop on the heel makes getting the shoes on easier.
  • Most buyers agree that the Hoka standard for well-built shoes and quality design shines through in these shoes.
  • One reviewer noted that these shoes have help reduce the knee pain he felt while getting back into running to lose weight.
Negative
  • As with some other Hoka shoes, the style and look of the Mafate Speed keeps some people from fully appreciating the features they offer.
  • Many reviews, both positive and negative, note that buying a half to full size larger than normal is necessary for most people.
  • These shoes have a narrow design which can't accommodate all widths of feet.
  • Some styles aren't available in wide sizes.
  • There are several negative notes about the tongue design. Some say it is too thin, some say it is too long. In both cases, people noted some rub and discomfort.
  • There are a few claims of fast wear on the tread and upper near the toes.
  • With the height of the shoe and the narrow fit, running on soft dirt can lead to less stable footing.
  • For a few reviewers, the upper feels too structured; especially compared to the original Mafate.
  • There are a few reports of blisters after a few months of use. One reviewer noted that this could be do to the weakening of the upper near the toe box creating rub.
  • There are several complaints about the lacing system. It can feel tight for people with high arches.
  • It is noted that these are more expensive than some other brands of running shoes.
  • One buyer complained about the color dye in the upper bleeding onto socks.
Reviewmeter
The Reviewmeter shows you an overall score that you can easily refer to. The highest rating is 10 (100% positive feedback)
Of the 155 reviews we found in total, 16% were negative, and 84% were positive.
8.4
1
5
10
Outsole
Outsole

Outsole

The Hoka One One Mafate Speed outsole is comprised of RMAT over layers of EVA foam which adds durability. Runners may find the high abrasion rubber to be a bit sparse to provide the level of durability Hoka One One users are accustomed to. However, the wide outsole platform of this trail-running shoe does provide the stability necessary for endurance runs or sprints. The outsole definitely delivers the kind of durability and traction needed for the daily run, if not so much for off-trail running. The combination of materials is perfectly balanced for hitting the turf and hold up well, even on an all-day marathon event.
Midsole
Midsole

Midsole

Hoka One One has a reputation for comfortable support and they live up to their name in the creation of this midsole. The CMEVA upper midsole gives this shoe the classic Hoka One One “cloud-like” quality, with a comfort that the foot will sink into. The EVA foam is about 30% lighter than your standard running shoes and is definitively more voluminous, helping to evenly distribute shock from heel strikes. The overall geometry of the midsole is great for daily runs, providing cushioned comfort, while still delivering on the desired level of support.
Upper
Upper

Upper

Sweaty, hot feet on a marathon is not the runner’s idea of comfort. However, neither does a sprinter want dirt and debris coming through a wide mesh cover. This shoe will satisfy desires on both accounts. The upper on the Hoka One One Mafate speed is a breathable synthetic textile which delivers on comfort, if not on high durability. The upper is also an easy clean when using a hose and cloth, which will be a definitive comfort after a day on a muddy trail. This no-seam fabric also reduces irritation and chafing due to its smooth weave and speed lacing system, although this does present problems for creating a stable lock.
Weight
Weight

Weight

The average Hoka One One Mafate Speed for men comes in at 10.2 oz a lightweight for fast, long runs. The weight is a definitive improvement for runners who had been asking the company to produce a lighter option for the runner who focuses on speed. The average women’s shoe in the same category came in even lighter at around 9.6 oz, providing a nearly weightless effect at high speeds. The shoe is relatively lightweight overall, providing a buoyant feeling on mild to technical terrain runs. The lightness of the shoe is probably one of its best features and impresses nearly every runner. Users find the shoe to be an easy go-to for the regular run, not adding needless burdens for the long stretch or the sprint.
Breathability
Breathability

Breathability

The no-sew upper of the shoe is comprised of an AirMesh that provides superior breathability. The mesh is made of a synthetic, flexible material sure to please and help mitigate sweat and chafing. The user looking for premium airflow is certain to be pleased with the Hoka One One Mafate Speed. The mesh fabric allows the comfort of airflow, without the discomfort of debris penetration. Users also found the shoe to remain comfortable even in muddy conditions where water might be expected to be an issue. The designers were able to combine fabrics in the perfect mix for a comfortably cool run whether on or off the trail.
Comfort
Comfort

Comfort

The shoe is designed with comfort at the forefront and any runner slipping their foot into this shoe will feel the utmost comfort. Layers of foam, an anatomically designed shoe, and supportive midsole ensure a comfortable fit for most users. The EVA upper midsole provides superior elevation which allows the foot to sink into a pillow-like feeling, as opposed to merely sitting on top. The problem sets in, however, when engaging in a run. The structure of the shoe, although it provides great support, may cause slippage. The forefoot of the shoe causes and awkward splay when striking the ground. These issues become especially noticeable during a longer run. Overall, the Hoka One One Mafate Speed does incorporate the comfort users expect from the brand.
Style
Style

Style

The Hoka One One Mafate was not necessarily created with style in mind. The shoe is obviously performance focused and is for the runner who doesn’t mind its bulky appearance. It has a broad profile but does come in a variety of colors to select from, so the user won’t be completely option-less when it comes to the appearance of their Hoka One One Mafate Speed. If the buyer is looking for a high-fashion running shoe that goes well with the Prada jogging suit, this is probably not the shoe they want. It has an appearance that gives the impression of its capabilities rather than its stylishness. All of that being said the shoe is not ugly, nor even unattractive. It’s simply not for the fashion-forward runner, but for the forward moving runner.
Durability
Durability

Durability

Hoka One One delivered on the request for a lighter, more flexible shoe; however, with that compromise in weight and stiffness seems to have come to a drop in durability as well. The central lugs showed signs of wear after about twenty miles of usage and high abrasion rubber was sparingly applied. The RMAT added under the layers of EVA foam, however, did help provide additional resilience. It has been used in 25K, 5K and various weather conditions and held up well, although there was a problem with the lugs experienced. Overall, the Mafate Speed is on middle ground for durability, neither the best nor the worst.
Protection
Protection

Protection

The mesh overlay on the Hoka One One Mafate Speed does provide great breathability. However, it does not compromise protection in any way. The AirMesh technology employed in this updated, lighter version of previous Mafate models, filters out unwanted debris which could cause chafing, including fine dirt. The High-Abrasion rubber stripping also helps to ensure the runner’s most valuable asset does not go unprotected.
Responsiveness
Responsiveness

Responsiveness

Users find the shoe to provide a superior response as the runner moves down the trail. The EVA midsole has appropriate support for a lateral run. However, moving up and downhill may still present a problem in this area as the shoe is a bit slow to give the desired feedback when moving at high speeds. Yet, the quality of the support combats the stiffness of the heel cup to give reasonable, if not excellent responsiveness during a level trail run. It’s also worthwhile to note that, although users found the treads to wear down in a short amount of time, the midsole gives excellent performance throughout the life of the shoe.
Support
Support

Support

The combination of the layered AirMesh upper, cushioned midsole, and overall geometry of the Hoka One One Mafate Speed provides the perfect combination to deliver on support. Whether it’s a morning sprint or a 25K run, this shoe will give the cloud-cushion Hoka One One has built its reputation on. From arch support to heel strike rebound, the Mafate Speed is the shoe for great support.
Terrain
Terrain

Terrain

The Hoka One One Mafate Speed is excellent for mid-terrains. However, reviews are mixed for tougher terrains as the treads sometimes don’t provide the traction needed to ensure proper strides. Also, the elevation of the ankle sometimes causes the users foot to feel unstable, especially during uphill runs. This shoe is still a great choice for the daily run on the trail, if not off.
Price
Price

Price

When the Hoka One One Mafate Speed was originally released the SRP was what some may have considered being cost prohibitive for an “iffy” purchase. However, many retailers are now discounting the shoe to prices under $100, dropping it into the category of a reasonable bargain for this level of a running shoe. For the technology and design of the shoe, it’s not a bad price range. Runners who want a good shoe for a fair price may find this shoe the one to meet their needs.
Traction
Traction

Traction

Reviews for the traction is mixed for the Hoka One One Mafate Speed. The treads on the shoe work well on trails, but not quite deep enough for many runners to be comfortable off the trail. Users also have found that the grip slips on many uphill runs, creating discomfort and fear of falling, not the best experience for the daily runner. However, the high-abrasion outsole does provide decent grip on the average surface.
Flexibility
Flexibility

Flexibility

The last Mafate released drew some complaints of stiffness. However, the decreased weight in the Mafate Speed is the perfect answer to this issue. Users find the lightweight shoe to provide flexibility that moves with the foot and delivers on performance during heavy strides and heel strikes. Overall, users find the shoe more agile than the previous versions of the Mafate.
Stability
Stability

Stability

Stability is another point of mixed reception for this edition of the Mafate. While some found the AirMesh layers and EVA foam to be well-structured for support, others found the ankle elevation to create an off-centered gravity for landing. The consensus, however, is that for running straight the shoe is great, although medial-lateral running is questionable. The lack of stability for all users across the board may indicate a quality control issue more than a design flaw.
Drop
Drop

Drop

The Hoka One One Mafate Speed features a 4mm heel-to-toe drop which definitely encourages a smooth midfoot/forefoot strike. This gives the runner a nice, natural propulsion when running as there is no jarring effect on the stride. The geometric structure of the shoe is partially defined by this drop as it promotes a forward momentum reduces the impact of heel striking, especially critical since the heel cup is so stiff in this shoe.
Key Features
Key Features

Key Features

• AirMesh seamless synthetic fabric uppers
• Active Foot Frame midsole geometry
• CMEVA upper midsole
• High-Abrasion Rubber Stripping
• RMAT layers with EVA foam outsole
Bottom Line
Bottom Line

Bottom Line

The Hoka One One is a brand that’s known for producing excellent quality, high-endurance, high-performance shoes. The Hoka One One Mafate Speed is no exception to this tradition of reliable shoes, although there are exceptions to when the shoe performs well and when it doesn’t. The geometry, structure and material of the shoe demonstrates the focus of the designers: comfort and speed.

Durability played second in this shoe’s configuration and even the focus of the shoe didn’t always miss the mark, as a sliding foot and awkward splay do not make for a comfortable run. However, the Hoka One One specialization in midsoles and breathable uppers make this shoe a viable option for hitting the trail. It’s a great choice for the endurance runners on non-technical, lateral to medial terrain. Users looking for a shoe that delivers on comfort and speed will not be disappointed with it. However, buyers should beware that if they want to go off the beaten path, they may wish for a different selection.

Overall, the Hoka One One Mafate Speed is a comfortable shoe which supports speed and will not overtax the purchaser’s purse.