to top 10 table

Top 10 Best Meal Replacement Shakes

last updated Jan 11, 2019
Most of today’s runners and athletes have no time to prepare a proper home-cooked meal before they leave for work, school, or the gym. With just a short time left for meal-planning, they have to make the best use of it to ensure they provide proper supplements to the body. Portable meal replacement shakes are convenient because they can be taken on the go and provide the protein, carbs, and vitamins needed to fuel the muscles of athletes and help them to achieve their goals. You should also consume them because they can suppress your appetite and aid in weight loss. If these seem like what you would want, below is our list of the top 10 best meal replacement shakes any runner or athlete should consider when looking to achieve their training goals.

In a Hurry? The test winner after 22 hrs of research

icon
Garden of Life
96.5/100 our score
Features
96
Advanced Features
98
Portability
97
Value
95
Garden of Life
Why is it better?

100% organic food

Free of banned substances

A perfect on-the-go meal

Contains no GMOs or hormones

In a Hurry? Editors choice:
Garden of Life
Test Winner: Garden of Life
Researched Sources
4
Researched Sources
Reviews Considered
1.5k
Reviews Considered
Hours Researching
22
Hours Researching
Products Evaluated
16
Products Evaluated
Sorting Options
Features Advanced Features Portability Value By Default
Rank
PictureProduct
Name
Rating
Shops
1
The rating is based on the average rating (1-100) from all the criteria in which we rated this product.
96.5
Features
96%
Advanced Features
98%
Portability
97%
Value
95%
Price Comparison Last Updated (22.01.19)
$25.54
2
The rating is based on the average rating (1-100) from all the criteria in which we rated this product.
95.5
Features
97%
Advanced Features
95%
Portability
96%
Value
94%
Price Comparison Last Updated (22.01.19)
$31.20
3
The rating is based on the average rating (1-100) from all the criteria in which we rated this product.
94.3
Features
97%
Advanced Features
94%
Portability
94%
Value
92%
Price Comparison Last Updated (22.01.19)
$49.25
4
The rating is based on the average rating (1-100) from all the criteria in which we rated this product.
93
Features
95%
Advanced Features
93%
Portability
94%
Value
90%
Price Comparison Last Updated (22.01.19)
$17.98
5
The rating is based on the average rating (1-100) from all the criteria in which we rated this product.
91.8
Features
92%
Advanced Features
93%
Portability
92%
Value
90%
Price Comparison Last Updated (22.01.19)
$23.20
6
The rating is based on the average rating (1-100) from all the criteria in which we rated this product.
91
Features
93%
Advanced Features
90%
Portability
90%
Value
91%
Price Comparison Last Updated (22.01.19)
$31.97
7
The rating is based on the average rating (1-100) from all the criteria in which we rated this product.
89.8
Features
90%
Advanced Features
92%
Portability
88%
Value
89%
Price Comparison Last Updated (22.01.19)
$70.00
8
The rating is based on the average rating (1-100) from all the criteria in which we rated this product.
88.8
Features
88%
Advanced Features
90%
Portability
91%
Value
86%
Price Comparison Last Updated (22.01.19)
$53.99
9
The rating is based on the average rating (1-100) from all the criteria in which we rated this product.
87.3
Features
87%
Advanced Features
86%
Portability
91%
Value
85%
Price Comparison Last Updated (22.01.19)
$58.99
10
The rating is based on the average rating (1-100) from all the criteria in which we rated this product.
85.8
Features
85%
Advanced Features
84%
Portability
90%
Value
84%
Price Comparison Last Updated (22.01.19)
$57.99
In Depth Review Top 10
  • Garden of Life
  • Soylent
  • IdealShake
  • Pure Protein
  • Vegansmart
  • RSP TrueFit
  • Keto Chow
  • KetoLogic
  • Advocare
  • PrimaForce
Table of contents
  • Criteria Used for Evaluation
  • Other Factors to Consider
  • Frequently Asked Questions
  • Sources

Top 10 Best Meal Replacement Shakes

1. Garden of Life

The rating is based on the average rating (1-100) from all the criteria in which we rated this product.
96.5
Garden of Life
Features
96
Advanced Features
98
Portability
97
Value
95
best offer for today
$25.54
Pros:

100% organic food

Free of banned substances

A perfect on-the-go meal

Contains no GMOs or hormones

Cons:

Contains many ingredients, which can be confusing

The taste may not be great

The organic meal replacement contains the nutrition required by runners and athletes to achieve greatness, including 5 grams fiber, enzymes, probiotics, and minerals. It also contains vitamins, less than a gram of sugar, and healthy fat. You will be able to satisfy your hunger with this organic on-the-go meal, packed with incredible nutrition.

Read more

Trusted by Sport

It contains no banned substances and is ideal for sports. The nutritional supplement assures runners that it has been tested by the sports anti-doping lab and found to be free of any prohibited substances.

USDA Organic

The company has shown a great deal of commitment toward clean ingredients, with 100% organic feed. It contains no prohibited pesticides, herbicides, or fungicides. There are also no hormones or GMOs.

Cost and Value

Having been tested by the world class sports anti-doping lab and found to be free of any prohibited substances, it qualifies to be a nutritional supplement of choice. In addition, the price is pocket-friendly.

2. Soylent

The rating is based on the average rating (1-100) from all the criteria in which we rated this product.
95.5
Soylent
Features
97
Advanced Features
95
Portability
96
Value
94
best offer for today
$31.20
Pros:

Soylent is nutritional and ready to drink

A complete meal replacement

Convenient nutrition with 20 percent of daily vitamin needs

Plant-based and vegan-friendly

Cons:

The cost can be a bit high

Some users have fallen sick after using Soylent

Soylent’s Classic Cacao flavor not only has a sweet subtle taste but also contains no added caffeine. This on-the-go ready-to-drink meal delivers 400 kcal, with about 26 vitamins and another 20g of plant-based protein. Runners and athletes who have skipped breakfast can pack this replacement meal and have it on the go for complete nutrition.

Read more

20g of Soy Protein

Soylent’s soy protein isolate delivers a smooth texture and is filled with a robust amino acid profile. Professional athletes know the importance of soy protein and would be glad to add it to their diet.

500mg Omega-3s

Soylent is also a great source of high-quality monounsaturated fats, with 0g of trans fat for every serving, thanks to the high oleic sunflower oil in it.

Cost and Value

Each ingredient in Soylent is carefully chosen to help deliver a delicious meal that anyone can take with them to wherever they are going. It only costs a few dollars.

3. IdealShake

The rating is based on the average rating (1-100) from all the criteria in which we rated this product.
94.3
IdealShake
Features
97
Advanced Features
94
Portability
94
Value
92
best offer for today
$49.25
Pros:

Blocks hunger for 3 hours

Reduces calories and helps to lose

Contains all-whey protein to nourish the body

Promotes lean muscle mass

Cons:

Can be a bit light or watery

The aftertaste can be terrible

The truth is that hunger and cravings can be very difficult to control or block. Even reducing your calorie intake is not a guarantee you will lose weight as you wish to. Fortunately, there seems to be a practical solution that will allow you to sip through a straw and not worry about your weight. IdealShake is simple yet deliciously tasty as well.

Read more

Hunger Control

IdealShake is celebrated for being able to block or suppress hunger for up to 3 hours. Once you are able to control your hunger, you can be able to avoid unnecessary eating and weight gain.

Promotes Lean Muscle

With 11g of whey protein contained in virtually all serving, the supplement is designed for daily exercise and could help to speed up the process of fat loss.

Cost and Value

Athletes who have the desire to control their cravings by reducing calories and promoting weight loss should try IdealShake. It is also affordable and could block hunger for 3 hours.

4. Pure Protein

The rating is based on the average rating (1-100) from all the criteria in which we rated this product.
93
Pure Protein
Features
95
Advanced Features
93
Portability
94
Value
90
best offer for today
$17.98
Pros:

Contains protein that helps to build muscle

Prepares the athlete to perform

Delivers the benefits of whey protein

Makes a great pre- and post-workout

Cons:

Some users fall sick after using the product

The chocolate may not taste like chocolate

As an athlete, you need to fuel your muscles and improve your athletic performance. Pure Protein is packed with all the benefits of whey protein. Protein is the basic building block of the muscles and could give you strength. A high-protein diet with complex carbs is all an athlete needs to take his or her performance to another level.

Read more

Improve Athletic Performance

Pure Protein is designed to build muscle and provide strength for overall improved performance. Therefore, only consume it when you are ready to perform.

Delivers the Benefits of Whey Protein

Any professional athlete cannot overlook the importance of whey protein derived from milk. Pure Protein contains the essential amino acids the body requires to support lean muscle and provide strength.

Cost and Value

Whether you are looking to improve your athletic performance or get all the benefits of whey protein while jogging or doing any other form of exercise, you can count on Pure Protein to support your cause. It is pocket-friendly as well.

5. Vegansmart

The rating is based on the average rating (1-100) from all the criteria in which we rated this product.
91.8
Vegansmart
Features
92
Advanced Features
93
Portability
92
Value
90
best offer for today
$23.20
Pros:

Contains five different plant-based proteins

Contains fruits and vegetables with antioxidant properties

The 22 vitamins and minerals support normal cell function

200g of Omega-3 support a healthy brain

Cons:

The smell of the supplement may not appeal to all

The aftertaste may be unpleasant

Vegansmart is yet another meal replacement shake that has appealed to the taste of many runners and athletes. It is a great source of nutrients and delivers a full meal with just a few scoops. It contains 20g of plant-based protein and is suitable for the whole family. For optimal result, you can have two or more servings daily.

Read more

Complete Protein Blend

Vegansmart boasts five different plant-based proteins with all the essential amino acids your body needs when exercising or building muscle. They are available in the right proportions and can help to repair muscle tissue.

Whole Food Complex

With 9 different highly-nutrition and colorful fruits, you will be sure to enjoy antioxidants and polyphenols. All these together with flavonoids can help to support your overall wellness.

Cost and Value

Not only does it contain a blend of plant-based protein, but also boasts naturally-occurring antioxidants and flavonoids that can be very beneficial to the body. The cost is never far away from reach.

6. RSP TrueFit

The rating is based on the average rating (1-100) from all the criteria in which we rated this product.
91
RSP TrueFit
Features
93
Advanced Features
90
Portability
90
Value
91
best offer for today
$31.97
Pros:

Contains grass-fed Whey protein and real food ingredients

Is a great post-workout, on-the-go nutrition option, and anytime meal replacement

Makes a nutritious breakfast

Aids in recovery after a workout

Cons:

The aftertaste can be unpleasant

Can be grainy

RSP TrueFit has proven to be very effective in maintaining your weight management goals. Not only is it great tasting, but also well-balanced and contains high-quality protein. It contains 16 essential vitamins as well as highly beneficial minerals. The 8g of fiber helps in suppressing appetite, making you feel fuller for longer. With only 4g of net carbs, this brand qualifies as a low carb diet.

Read more

Weight Management

TrueFit is suitable when you want to keep your weight in check. It contains fiber that will keep you fuller for longer and is a great low carb diet.

Grass-Fed Protein

TrueFit boasts grass-fed Whey Protein, with high-quality probiotics. If you are looking for whole food nutrition, you can be sure they will deliver.

Cost and Value

For many runners and athletes, weight management goals often top the list. This grass-fed Whey protein is an effective weight manager with fiber to help suppress appetite. It is also affordable.

7. Keto Chow

The rating is based on the average rating (1-100) from all the criteria in which we rated this product.
89.8
Keto Chow
Features
90
Advanced Features
92
Portability
88
Value
89
best offer for today
$70.00
Pros:

Ultra low carbs

Complete nutrition for the typical nutritional ketosis

Supplies the body with electrolytes to make up for any deficiencies

Makes a perfect on-the-go meal

Cons:

Not every athlete will like the taste

May not smell great to everyone

The drink mix makes a complete keto meal instantly. While it is not meant to be a replacement for bacon and steak, it makes a great meal for any time of the day. Whether you are late for a meeting, need to have breakfast in your car, stuck in traffic and needs a snack, or want to hit the gym while having a meal to supplement, Keto Chow is an excellent addition to your snacking program.

Read more

A Complete Keto Meal

Keto Chow is designed to be complete nutrition ideal for Nutritional Ketosis. It mixes easily and makes a complete keto meal.

On-the-go Meal

As a busy athlete or runner, you are always in a hurry to accomplish your runs and resume your work or school life. Keto Chow can be packed for breakfast as you head to the gym or work.

Cost and Value

It provides one-third of your daily electrolyte needs, with protein and vitamins to supplement your daily intake of the same. You can also pack and have it on the go. It is quite affordable as well.

8. KetoLogic

The rating is based on the average rating (1-100) from all the criteria in which we rated this product.
88.8
KetoLogic
Features
88
Advanced Features
90
Portability
91
Value
86
best offer for today
$53.99
Pros:

A satiating fuel source for all runners

Blends smoothly with water

Promotes weight loss

Blends smoothly with water

Cons:

May cause gastrointestinal distress

Can cause cramping after consumption

MCTs are found in coconut oil and form the key fat molecules and provide a reliable source of fuel to help propel the body and push the athlete to achieve his or her goals. The health benefits have been clinically studied and ascertained to help athletes to achieve their goals. However, MCTs should be taken in moderation to avoid gastrointestinal distress.

Read more

Facilitates Fat Loss

Loaded with MCTs, KetoLogic effectively promotes fat loss and fat oxidation. It also boosts metabolism, thereby helping to keep your overall body weight in check.

Suppresses Appetite

Apparently, Ketologic is known for suppressing appetite and making you feel fuller for longer. After consuming it, you will feel fuller for longer, allowing you to replace your breakfast or even lunch and cut down on those excess calories that could spell disaster.

Cost and Value

With KetoLogic Meal Replacement (MRP), you will conveniently replace your breakfast or lunch with a suppressed appetite, allowing you to control your weight as an athlete. It is also pocket-friendly.

9. Advocare

The rating is based on the average rating (1-100) from all the criteria in which we rated this product.
87.3
Advocare
Features
87
Advanced Features
86
Portability
91
Value
85
best offer for today
$58.99
Pros:

Delicious and portable

Blended with protein, carbs, and fiber

Excellent fuel for the muscles

Great for weight management

Cons:

The taste may not be great

The smell may not appeal to everyone

Advocare has specialized in making delicious, portable shake mixes that provide a blend of protein for muscle tissue repair, carbohydrates for energy, and fiber to help suppress appetite while keeping you fueled and ready to jog and win all day long. It also contains 26 vitamins, with 210-220 calories per serving. The shakes are easily digestible and can be a great addition to virtually any athlete’s weight-management program.

Read more

Portable Shake Mix

This portable supplement contains protein, carbohydrates, and fiber to ensure the athlete receives the much-needed fuel needed to perform athletic tasks.

A Great Part of any Weight Management Program

It is easily digestible and would form an excellent part of any weight management program. It is great for athletes looking to manage their weight.

Cost and Value

With protein, carbs, and fiber blended into the meal replacement shake, you can be sure that your supplement will contain everything needed to take you through a morning run at an affordable price.

10. PrimaForce

The rating is based on the average rating (1-100) from all the criteria in which we rated this product.
85.8
PrimaForce
Features
85
Advanced Features
84
Portability
90
Value
84
best offer for today
$57.99
Pros:

A delicious fuel source of fuel

Aids in fat loss

Boosts ketone production

Suppresses appetite

Cons:

The cost can be a bit high

Nausea is reported as one of the side effects

PrimaForce KetoShakes contains coconut oil and MCTs (Medium-Chain Triglycerides), which are converted to ketones by the body. The brain and muscles efficiently use ketones as a superior fuel. It generates more energy (ATP) for every unit of oxygen consumed by the user than protein or carbs do. Incorporating PrimaForce into your morning routine as your breakfast can be a very ideal strategy to fuel your muscles.

Read more

Convenient and Delicious

Professional athletes and nutritionists would generally agree that PrimaForce KetoShakes can be a convenient and a delicious source of fuel, especially for individuals with low-carb/ketogenic diet needs.

Promotes Fat Loss

With MCTs to promote weight loss and the oxidation of fat while boosting metabolism, PrimaForce KetoShakes is your ideal partner if you are looking to lose weight as an athlete.

Cost and Value

To conveniently and reliably fuel your muscles, you need a delicious, low-carb or ketogenic diet. It also contains MCTs to promote fat loss and ensure a healthy body weight. For 20servings, the price is fair.

Criteria Used for Evaluation

Features

This is a critical factor to consider because your entire health depends on it. You have to pay close attention to what makes up the food you are going to consume. The result of consuming unhealthy ingredients can be fatal. With several brands available today, it is a challenge for many people to select the best shakes for their nutrition plan. Going through the list of ingredients will help you determine whether you are consuming a healthier option or not. Some of them may contain excess sugar, preservatives, or any other ingredients considered to be potentially harmful to the body. In addition, every product is different, with different ingredients and in different quantities. While some may be high in sodium, others have less or none of this element. Those with high amounts of sodium in them may not be ideal for individuals who have a problem with their blood pressure. This makes it very important for individuals with blood pressure issues to carefully go through the list of ingredients and ascertain that little to no sodium is used to make their ideal product before they can make the ultimate purchase decision. Others still may contain potentially harmful preservatives or excess carbs and sugars, which may risk the life of some consumers. In particular, excess sugar and carbs can be unhealthy for individual athletes with blood sugar issues. In addition, if you are trying to lose weight, you obviously do not want anything that may suggest excess carbs or sugar.

Considering the ingredients used could also help you to avoid unhealthy shakes. If anything, they are meant to help you resist cravings or the urge to indulge in processed foods and food items that can be unhealthy. For many people, the biggest challenge when it comes to losing weight is the substantial amount of time required to prepare a proper meal at home. Today, most people do not have the luxury of time. As a result, they resort to fast foods that are an unhealthy food option, which they consume in large amounts to satisfy their hunger. Unfortunately, processed sugars, salts, and fats found in these fast foods lead to more intense cravings for these types of foods. Therefore, the more they eat these foods the more want them, thereby causing them to develop very unhealthy habits as far as food choice is concerned.

Fortunately, the emergence of meal replacement shakes has given people healthier food alternatives, which they can pack when in a hurry for later consumption. Therefore, you can grab your pack when in a hurry or when stressed on your way to work and you can be sure you will have a healthier breakfast or lunch than you would have if you ended up in a fast food joint. Note that fast foods seriously thwart your weight loss efforts and may lead to serious heart health issues. Overall, avoid meals full of sugar, preservatives or other artificial ingredients, and refined carbs. Not only do they lack beneficial nutrients, but may also threaten your health.

Advanced Features

Another closely-related factor is the ingredients. Since you are looking to replace your regular meal with a diet that contains all of the essential nutrients your brain, body, and organs need to function normally, you need to ensure it contains all of the major nutrients. These nutrients should also be balanced or in the right proportion. For instance, as an athlete, you need a sufficient amount of protein to help repair worn out muscle tissues. In this regard, you should aim for a minimum of 15g of protein per serving. Whether you are a runner, a bodybuilder, or an athlete who participants in ball games and team sports, you need to constantly repair your muscles or eat food that will build them and boost your strength. This makes the amount of proteins per serving very important. Typically, the more the protein content the better. On the other hand, fiber should also be available in sufficient amounts, typically more than 3 grams per serving.

Overall, they are known to provide all of the essential nutrients you would not ordinarily find in regular meals. Look for shakes with 200-400 calories and a substantial amount of protein, carefully balanced with carbs, fiber, and essential vitamins and minerals to make your meal complete. While it is recommended to consider these amounts of calories, you should also keep in mind that their nutrient compositions may vary substantially, with different amounts of protein, carbs, and even fat. Ideally, they are meant to provide nutrients that are generally lacking in traditional diets. With all the nutrients you can only consume in a home-based and home-prepared meal, these shakes are your ideal option when you are looking to replace your regular meal and lose weight in the long-term. It is often challenging to cut back on calories whilst getting all of the essential nutrients your body needs to function optimally. Indeed, they are fortified with nutrients that can be used to fill an athlete’s nutrient gap while also cutting back on calories.

Portability

It is for this reason that meal replacement shakes are referred to as on-the-go meals. Portability is a very crucial factor to consider. Many people, including athletes and runners, are always busy and rarely have time to prepare a good meal or take their supplements at home. Therefore, you should consider how portable your ideal food supplement is. Remember you are going to replace your breakfast, lunch, or dinner, and you need to have your alternative on the go. You should be able to pack your ideal supplement and consume it on your way to the gym, work, or school. If you cannot carry it to wherever you are going, you may want to change your choice and go for a more portable alternative. This will save you plenty of time in the end and you will be glad you chose a portable alternative. Today’s super busy work or school lifestyle requires a great deal of convenience.

Value

The truth is that many meal replacement shakes out there are not cheap. You will have to spend anywhere from tens to hundreds of dollars. If you are not ready to part with that kind of money, then this option is not for you and you should stick to your routine diet. However, you should also keep in mind that expensive does not always equate to good quality. Similarly, finding the cheapest brand on the market because you are on a budget may also give you the results you are looking for. Therefore, you should always find a balance between cost and quality. Always try to avoid both extremes. You don’t have to break the bank so that you can be able to afford a meal replacement. The general perception out there is that the most expensive ones are of the best quality. While there is some truth to that notion or perception, this may not always be true.

You may also not be able to buy them in bulk and only spend negligible pennies per serving, spread across the week or month to give you good value for money, but this does not mean you can’t save some money. In fact, you can be on the lookout for discounts or any other offers that could help you get good value for your money. Many people would agree they are as expensive as eating out in a decent restaurant, which can get very expensive if you do so on a daily basis. Regardless, ensure you do your due diligence to ensure you get the best quality at the best price. By comparing prices and choosing the most pocket-friendly alternatives, you can be able to save money in the long-run. Don’t go broke buying the most expensive shakes on the market.

Expert Interviews & Opinions

Most Important Criteria (According to our experts opinion)
Sort criterias acording to:
Experts Opinion Editors Opinion Users Opinion By Default
Click on a to rate the most important criteria:
1
Advanced Features
Rate This Criteria as Most Important
2
Features
Rate This Criteria as Most Important
3
Portability
Rate This Criteria as Most Important
4
Value
Rate This Criteria as Most Important
Don't X out food completely, it wouldn't be healthy.

When choosing a meal replacement drink, they are perfectly fine as long as its once in a while, and they have a nutritional hold to them. One that fills your stomach without ruining your weight loss efforts.

Shakes

Meal replacement drinks were made for those gym fanatics that need an extra nutritous boost before or after a workout, they have now moved mainstream. Make sure when finding one for you, to check with your doctor before supplmenting any food from out your day.

Other Factors to Consider

Bottom Line

Selecting the best meal replacement shake requires that you consider several factors, including the ability to support weight loss goals, the ingredients used, flavor, and even budget among other factors. The amount of protein, carbs, and fiber per service is also an important point to note. Do not forget to look at the taste of the supplement, as you do not want to have a horrible aftertaste every time you consume your supplement. Athletes and runners look for these types of supplements to ensure they lower the number of calories consumed for overall weight loss.

Frequently Asked Questions

q: What are meal replacement shakes?
a:

These are healthy food alternatives packed in a bottle or can, usually in powder form and can be mixed with water or milk to make them ready for consumption. They provide the body with the same nutrition you would ordinarily receive in a complete meal.

q: What is the difference between a protein shake and meal replacement shake?
a:

Many people often fail to notice the difference between the two. However, just as the names suggest, protein shakes are saturated with proteins and supply athletes with the proteins they need to build muscle and strength. They provide the extra calories required to make up for the deficiency. In contrast, meal replacement shakes help to achieve the nutrition delivered by a full meal. This means you do not need to consume an entire meal to get all the essential nutrients your body needs, as they are all available in a simple bottle or package.

q: How is a protein shake different from a meal replacement shake?
a:

The major difference is in the ingredients used. While a protein shake is primarily made of whey protein, the latter features vitamins and minerals as part of the ingredients, making it a complete and all-rounded meal. In addition, the former is taken to supplement a balanced diet whereas the latter can be used to completely replace a meal.

q: Why would I need meal replacement shakes?
a:

They are a healthier alternative to fast foods. They are also great if you are busy and looking for a quick breakfast idea, as they are a nutritious alternative, without the saturated fats commonly found in processed foods. They are also better than skipping meals.

q: How can I choose the best meal replacement shake?
a:

Your ideal choice should be high in protein and low in net carbs. Excess carbs can be converted into sugar, which is later converted to fat and stored in the body.

q: How many calories should a meal replacement shake contain?
a:

It should typically contain somewhere between 200-400 calories. This will ensure there are no excess calories that can be stored in your body as fat.