to top 10 table

10 Best Ice Packs for Runners Tested

last updated Jan 17, 2019
The best ice packs can be hard to find—and when it comes to healing injuries, your body deserves better than a bag of frozen vegetables. If you have a recent injury where swelling is an issue, ice can be the best treatment for not only decreasing your pain but also reducing inflammation and speeding the healing process. The companies who make the ice packs on our list employ experts who conduct extensive research to ensure the design and application will give you the maximum benefits of ice without doing any damage. We looked at the best ice packs on the market and chose the 10 that are best for runners, to help you heal quickly and get back out there.

In a Hurry? The test winner after 14 hrs of research

icon
FlexiKold Gel
94.8/100 our score
Materials
94
Durability
93
Value
95
Ease of Use
95
Versatility
97
FlexiKold Gel
Why is it better?

Covers a really wide area of the body

Stays cold for hours so you can sleep with it

The material is easy to clean

Many sizes available

Perfect to use on your back

In a Hurry? Editors choice:
FlexiKold Gel
Test Winner: FlexiKold Gel
Researched Sources
14
Researched Sources
Reviews Considered
1200
Reviews Considered
Hours Researching
14
Hours Researching
Products Evaluated
20
Products Evaluated
Last Updated:
Avatar
By Giselle Killebrew:

Currently we have added the Koo Care 2, Therapaq, and the Natracure ice packs. These are all affordable options that provide different benefits that runners are sure to love. Be sure to check our FAQ sections to answer any questions you may have.

Sorting Options
Materials Durability Value Ease of Use Versatility By Default
Rank
PictureProduct
Name
Rating
Shops
#1
The rating is based on the average rating (1-100) from all the criteria in which we rated this product.
94.8
Materials
94%
Durability
93%
Value
95%
Ease of Use
95%
Versatility
97%
Price Comparison Last Updated (16.02.19)
$14.99
#2
The rating is based on the average rating (1-100) from all the criteria in which we rated this product.
94
Materials
93%
Durability
93%
Value
94%
Ease of Use
97%
Versatility
93%
Price Comparison Last Updated (16.02.19)
$7.15
#3
The rating is based on the average rating (1-100) from all the criteria in which we rated this product.
91
Materials
95%
Durability
90%
Value
87%
Ease of Use
93%
Versatility
90%
Price Comparison Last Updated (16.02.19)
$24.99
#4
The rating is based on the average rating (1-100) from all the criteria in which we rated this product.
88.4
Materials
95%
Durability
92%
Value
90%
Ease of Use
85%
Versatility
80%
Price Comparison Last Updated (16.02.19)
$33.95
#5
The rating is based on the average rating (1-100) from all the criteria in which we rated this product.
87.6
Materials
90%
Durability
85%
Value
81%
Ease of Use
90%
Versatility
92%
Price Comparison Last Updated (16.02.19)
$14.90
#6
The rating is based on the average rating (1-100) from all the criteria in which we rated this product.
85.8
Materials
82%
Durability
85%
Value
83%
Ease of Use
90%
Versatility
89%
Price Comparison Last Updated (16.02.19)
$20.80
#7
The rating is based on the average rating (1-100) from all the criteria in which we rated this product.
84
Materials
86%
Durability
86%
Value
85%
Ease of Use
80%
Versatility
83%
Price Comparison Last Updated (16.02.19)
$18.01
#8
The rating is based on the average rating (1-100) from all the criteria in which we rated this product.
82.8
Materials
90%
Durability
89%
Value
80%
Ease of Use
80%
Versatility
75%
Price Comparison Last Updated (16.02.19)
$21.61
#9
The rating is based on the average rating (1-100) from all the criteria in which we rated this product.
81.4
Materials
80%
Durability
78%
Value
74%
Ease of Use
83%
Versatility
92%
Price Comparison Last Updated (16.02.19)
$9.99
#10
The rating is based on the average rating (1-100) from all the criteria in which we rated this product.
79
Materials
69%
Durability
70%
Value
75%
Ease of Use
95%
Versatility
86%
Price Comparison Last Updated (16.02.19)
$9.06
In Depth Review Top 10
  • FlexiKold Gel
  • Roscoe Medical Hot & Cold
  • The Coldest Water
  • O2 Cold Therapy with Compression
  • Koo Care 2
  • Therapaq
  • TheraPearl Shin Wraps
  • Polar Ice Foot and Ankle Wrap
  • NatraCure
  • CryoCup
Table of contents
  • Criteria Used for Evaluation
  • Other Factors to Consider
  • Frequently Asked Questions
  • Sources

Top 10 Ice Packs for Runners

1. FlexiKold Gel

The rating is based on the average rating (1-100) from all the criteria in which we rated this product.
94.8
FlexiKold Gel
Materials
94
Durability
93
Value
95
Ease of Use
95
Versatility
97
best offer for today
$14.99
Pros:

Covers a really wide area of the body

Stays cold for hours so you can sleep with it

The material is easy to clean

Many sizes available

Perfect to use on your back

Cons:

Buyers complained about not enough gel moving from side to side

While this is a basic ice pack, its quality materials and construction, large size, and tons of satisfied customers made us put it #1 on our list. It's big enough and flexible enough to use just about anywhere, and it's double sealed in order to prevent leaks.

Read more

The product is quite thin since there’s not a lot of gel in it, but it still gets super cold. As there’s less gel than in other products, it is more flexible and pliable. Helps with inflammation, swelling, and muscle pain. The nylon cover is smooth to the touch and much more comfortable than the plastic ones that come with many other products. There’s also a neck contour version available, specially designed for neck pain. A very durable and excellent product for frequent use. It’s more expensive than some other products on our list but it’s totally worth it.

2. Roscoe Medical Hot & Cold

The rating is based on the average rating (1-100) from all the criteria in which we rated this product.
94
Roscoe Medical Hot & Cold
Materials
93
Durability
93
Value
94
Ease of Use
97
Versatility
93
best offer for today
$7.15
Pros:

Helps assist with a variety of aches/pains in different body parts

Good for sprains, contusions, headaches, and even toothaches

Three convenient sizes

Won’t freeze solid like a block, maintains flexibility

Cons:

Has a chemical smell at first

There is nothing fancy about this ice pack but it’s a good place to start from. Everyone should have a couple of these handy packs around due to their versatility and effectiveness.

Read more

These type of packs are pretty common, but we included the one made by Roscoe Medical because of the strength of its seams. One drawback of these types of packs (especially with heavy repeated use) is that the seams can split leaving you with blue goo all over you and the couch. With the Roscoe Hot & Cold Pack, this should not be an issue.

3. The Coldest Water

The rating is based on the average rating (1-100) from all the criteria in which we rated this product.
91
The Coldest Water
Materials
95
Durability
90
Value
87
Ease of Use
93
Versatility
90
best offer for today
$24.99
Pros:

Retains the cold for a long time

Soft fabric covering

Cons:

It’s definitely on the more expensive side

If you’re looking for something bigger, you should definitely check out The Coldest Water ice pack. It’s 15.2 x 11.7 inches so it’s one of the biggest on our list.

Read more

This product was specially created for people who play sports. If you want to recover faster, this product will help and it’s great for fast pain relief. If you have any ankle sprains, back pain, or any other muscle pain, this pack will minimize it. The pack molds really well to the shape of your body, and provides relief to the appropriate area. However, for some users, the pack was too stiff and they felt there was a lack of flexibility. The material is very comfortable on the skin and you don’t feel like you're putting plastic on your body. Users were also amazed by the temperature of the pack. It retains the cold so well that some users described it as the coldest pack they had ever used. Even after 20 minutes of use, it stays cold. Another nice thing is that you don’t need a towel to use this pack to insulate yourself from cold burns.

4. O2 Cold Therapy with Compression

The rating is based on the average rating (1-100) from all the criteria in which we rated this product.
88.4
O2 Cold Therapy with Compression
Materials
95
Durability
92
Value
90
Ease of Use
85
Versatility
80
best offer for today
$33.95
Pros:

Ice and compression combined

Fits great around the knee

Very effective

Cons:

Some reports of durability issues with ice pack

Not good for skinny legs

This product is unique as it offers the user compression along with the healing effects of ice to help you recover faster. And it's specifically designed for use on knees, which any runner can appreciate. Compression increases blood circulation, so fresh oxygenated blood rushes to the area speeding healing.

Read more

Materials and Durability

This product is made with high-quality materials that have been approved by professional physical therapists who freeze, thaw, and re-freeze these ice packs constantly, so you know that if it will take that kind of continuous use it will hold up to use at your home. We did find a few reports from users that the ice pack portion of the product started to leak over time, but this is typical with this type of product and didn't seem to be a consistent issue.

Ease of Use and Versatility

Reviewers said that it was easy to use, both to put on the knee and to inflate for compression. Because of its knee specific design, this product isn't really that versatile.

Value

This product is one of the more expensive ones on our list, however for those looking for the healing effects of both ice and compression all in one product it will be money well spent.

5. Koo Care 2

The rating is based on the average rating (1-100) from all the criteria in which we rated this product.
87.6
Koo Care 2
Materials
90
Durability
85
Value
81
Ease of Use
90
Versatility
92
best offer for today
$14.90
Pros:

Affordable

Versatile

easy to use

Cons:

not as durable

The Koo Care 2 ice pack is affordable and easy to use. It is a great option for everyday use.

Read more

This ice pack is versatile and perfect for all areas of the body It comes with a one year warranty and is one of the most affordable options on our list.

6. Therapaq

The rating is based on the average rating (1-100) from all the criteria in which we rated this product.
85.8
Therapaq
Materials
82
Durability
85
Value
83
Ease of Use
90
Versatility
89
best offer for today
$20.80
Pros:

Relieves pain

Hot and cold therapy

Compression wrap

Cons:

Expensive

This is a gel icepack that will help relieve your pain and improve your overall range of motion if you are struggling with that. It is easy to use and great for the hip, shoulder, back, and knee.

Read more

This ice pack is perfect for athletes and the everyday person--it's easy to use and perfect for pain relief from arthritis or muscle pain. It provides hot or cold therapy and provides a compression fit for added relief. The best part is that it comes with a money back guarantee (although it is a bit pricey, to begin with).

7. TheraPearl Shin Wraps

The rating is based on the average rating (1-100) from all the criteria in which we rated this product.
84
TheraPearl Shin Wraps
Materials
86
Durability
86
Value
85
Ease of Use
80
Versatility
83
best offer for today
$18.01
Pros:

Perfect for shin splints, stress fractures and more

Holds temperature for the medically recommended period of time

Simply pop in the freezer or toss in the microwave

Made from non-toxic materials

Latex and BPA free

Cons:

Some wish that they would adjust tighter

The shins are one part of your body that can take a real beating when it comes to running. Shin splints, calf strains, stress fractures, you name it. Why not give them a bit of TLC?

Read more

The TheraPearl Shin Wraps are a great way to do this. They smoothly envelop your calves and shins and provide a calming chill or an invigorating burst of warmth (depending on what you need). These wraps have a double velcro adjustable strap set which makes sure that they stay in place. They also are guaranteed to hold their therapeutic temperature for a minimum of 20 minutes. Don’t let shin issues keep you out of commission, fight back with TheraPearl Wraps!

ProTip: These wraps are slim enough to fit underneath your pants, so if you want you can put them on at the office and take a load off your shins while you work.

8. Polar Ice Foot and Ankle Wrap

The rating is based on the average rating (1-100) from all the criteria in which we rated this product.
82.8
Polar Ice Foot and Ankle Wrap
Materials
90
Durability
89
Value
80
Ease of Use
80
Versatility
75
best offer for today
$21.61
Pros:

Great for cold therapy after surgery

Build to articulate perfectly around the ankle

Has hook & loop closure straps

Surface has soft fleece covering to protect skin

Cons:

It could be a bit more pliable

For any type of soft tissue trauma in the foot or ankle area, strapping on the Polar Ice Foot can be a great first step in healing the injury. Reduce swelling, control pain and get yourself back to full speed as soon as possible.

Read more

This is another custom designed icing implement that will more thoroughly cover your ankle than an all-purpose pack ever will. On the interior, the Polar Ice foot has encapsulated ice packs filled with purified water. On the exterior, you have a soft fleece that is easy on the skin and protects from frostbite. Combine the two with a smart design and you’ve got a winning ice pack.

9. NatraCure

The rating is based on the average rating (1-100) from all the criteria in which we rated this product.
81.4
NatraCure
Materials
80
Durability
78
Value
74
Ease of Use
83
Versatility
92
best offer for today
$9.99
Pros:

Versatile

can be wrapped

stays colder longer

Cons:

pricey

If you're a runner or an athlete then you will find this one to be one of the best options on our list.

Read more

This ice pack is designed to stay colder longer thanks to its trademarked clay pack. It is really lightweight flexible and built to last.

10. CryoCup

The rating is based on the average rating (1-100) from all the criteria in which we rated this product.
79
CryoCup
Materials
69
Durability
70
Value
75
Ease of Use
95
Versatility
86
best offer for today
$9.06
Pros:

User friendly, convenient, self-icing tool

Plastic handle does not conduct cold temperature leaving your hands unaffected; simply fill cup with water and put it in the freezer

Can be used for sensory stimulation, splint cooling, or general muscle work

Reusable (eco-friendly) and easy to clean

Easy to use

Cons:

May start to crack after long use, due to repeated hot/cold transitions

This is a handy ice massage tool that can breath new life into tired and sore muscles.

Read more

Research (and our own experience) shows that icing can be more effective when a good bit of pressure is applied. Add in the motion of moving the CryoCup around and it’s easy to understand how this method can reach deeper into the muscle tissue and achieve better results. One point of caution, however: when applying ice directly to the skin, be sure not to overexpose one area as this can result in frostbite. On the plus side, your fingers won’t freeze when applying the ice and this product is much more eco-friendly than throwing away a bunch of Dixie cups every week. If you’ve never tried it before, an ice massage can be exhilarating.

Criteria Used for Evaluation

Materials

The material the ice pack is made of should be high quality, durable, and pliable in order to fit to your body correctly. Seams must be well-made and they can’t split or you or your clothes may be colored by the gel or whatever other substance is used in the pack. After taking it out of the freezer, the gel or any other substance should be flexible to easily fit the shape of your body. This is actually one of the biggest complaints we hear about ice packs, that when they're frozen they aren't flexible enough to be of much use. Because of this we made sure to add several products that remain flexible even when completely frozen. Avoid products in which liquid substances stay only on one side of the pack. The majority of the ice packs that you buy may or may not have warning labels on them. Be sure to check over these ice packs, prior to use to see if the inner material is dangerous. These days most companies only use non-toxic substances in their products but you can never be too careful and it pays to double check before buying and using.

Durability

Obviously the durability of the ice pack is a really important factor to consider. You want something that you can use again and again, and that won't fail you when you need it the most. It's really annoying, and bad for your health, recovery, and training, to think you have an ice pack all set to go, only to pull it out of the freezer only to find the seams split and gel leaking out making it unusable.

We considered over 1300 reviews to see what users had to say about the durability of various products we were considering for our list. Some of the products are more durable than others, but we didn't include any that had a ton of complaints about the durability. Some of the things that make products like this durable are using high-quality materials, solid seam construction, and the quality of the gel or liquid used. Even if the exterior materials are of good quality, if the gel isn't it could lead to bursting and leaks in the ice pack, so you want to be sure that all of the materials used are high-quality, not just some of them.

Ease of Use

In all honesty, there shouldn't be too much thought that goes into the use of an ice pack. The aim is to relieve pain and stress by simply applying it and relaxing. Because of this, one of the most important aspects of a well-made ice pack is how easy it can be used in order to bring about this relief. Ice packs that offer specialty uses, such as those that target specific areas of the body such as knees, shins, or elbows are easier to use for these specific injuries but may not be easy to use overall and typically don't offer much in the way of versatility. The same is true for ice packs that double as heat packs, which most of the ones on our list do. So long as these products can be easily heated and/or chilled, their versatility shouldn't affect their ease of use.

Most ice packs, and the top ones on our list in fact, are of the most basic variety; flat and square or rectangular with no other features such as straps etc. Depending on where and how you plan on using the pack, this can actually make it easier or more difficult to use the pack. For example, if you want to lie down with an ice pack on your back, having straps or other attachments can get in the way and make it harder to use. But if you want to wrap the pack around a joint such as a knee or ankle then NOT having straps makes it much more difficult to use because you have to sit there and hold the pack for the 15-20 minutes of recommended icing time. Be sure to take all of this into consideration when making your selection, and since most of the products on our list are really affordable, as an investment in your health and wellbeing we recommend buying several different types of packs for different parts of your body.

Versatility

While choosing the best product, you should consider what’s the aim of its usage. If you’re going to use it on small parts of your body like knees or hands, you don’t need to purchase a big one. It’s a different story if you're looking for relief for your back, shoulders, or arms. You must be aware that an ice pack must fit around the whole area of the arm, leg etc. It’s usually better to buy a bigger one because while it may be a little heavier than a small, it will still work with smaller parts of the body, whereas small packs won't work for larger body parts. Remember also that even for the back, a product shouldn’t be too heavy because you may have a problem with keeping it in the freezer. Another thing to consider is the shape of the ice pack. The majority of ice packs that you buy may be shaped the same but in the event that you run into an oddly shaped ice pack, it may be more difficult for you to use on different parts of your body.

Value

Many people may think that ice packs shouldn’t be very expensive and they really aren’t. You have a wide range of prices- from 20 dollars products to those which price may be higher than 50 dollars. However, the most expensive products aren’t always the best ones. You should personalize your product. We would recommend checking the price after considering the other important factors. Remember also that if you need an ice pack for your back it won’t cost the same as an ice pack for the wrist. No matter what, you should never put a price limit on caring for your body. You need your body for all daily functions and its not worth being miserable and mistreating injuries.

On one hand, you can't put a price on effective injury treatment supplies. But on the other hand, no one wants to pay out the nose for an ice pack of all things! Some of the products on this list are certainly on the higher side of the price spectrum. However, all of the products listed here will provide real relief and treatment for serious injuries, which more than justifies the price in our eyes. Still, you may want to be mindful of the cost for each product when making a purchasing decision.

Expert Interviews & Opinions

Most Important Criteria (According to our experts opinion)
Sort criterias acording to:
Experts Opinion Editors Opinion Users Opinion By Default
Click on a to rate the most important criteria:
#1
Ease of Use
Rate This Criteria as Most Important
#2
Versatility
Rate This Criteria as Most Important
#3
Materials
Rate This Criteria as Most Important
#4
Durability
Rate This Criteria as Most Important
#5
Value
Rate This Criteria as Most Important
Follow the RICE Protocol

There's an effective method to treat most minor to moderate injuries that are caused by running. It's known as the RICE protocol. This is an acronym that stands for Rest, Ice, Compression, and Elevation. Essentially, you should immediately stop using the affected body part, apply ice to the hurt area, provide some compression, and keep the affected limb elevated. In most minor cases of injury, this is the most effective and time-saving method of treatment.

Don't Use Ice For Too Long!

Although the numbing effects of an ice pack on an injured area can be soothing to the point that you'll want to wear it for a long time, the truth is that you should only ice a particular body part for twenty minutes at a time. Failing to remember this rule can result in moderate to severe skin damage and increased pain.

Other Factors to Consider

Compression

Some of the ice packs listed here also offer the ability to provide compression to the affected area. This can be a useful design aspect since it allows for you to handle another important part of the typical treatment process when handling the vast majority of running injuries. However, compression isn't always the correct way to handle some running injuries, so it's worth considering whether or not you want to invest in a product that always compresses the affected region.

Frequently Asked Questions

q: What is the benefit of icing an injury?
a:

While there are many benefits to icing an injury, one of the main reasons ice is used as a go-to is because it just feels good. With that being said, there are also facts behind why icing is beneficial. Icing helps minimize swelling and also can reduce bleeding in the tissue, muscle spasms, and pain.

q: Can ice packs go bad?
a:

While some ice packs do have an expiration date, you do not always need to follow it. Icing can be done with an expired gel ice pack with no repercussions. When you start to ice, it works generally the same as a new, used, or expired ice pack. The dates that are listed on these ice packs are more of a recommendation date rather than an expiration date, and to be honest it's mostly a way to get unsuspecting people to buy more ice packs.

q: What should I consider before buying?
a:

Depending upon what you are looking for in an ice pack, there are several things to consider. The shape forming gel ice packs may be more beneficial for multi-purpose use, whereas hard ice packs will be difficult to use when icing around the wrist or other rounded body parts. These harder or firm ice packs can burn the skin by being too cold. With that said, think about what kind of injury that you are trying to heal.

q: How long should I ice my injury for?
a:

Experts usually recommend icing an injury for no longer than 20 minutes. We know how good ice feels on a swollen limb or joint, and that it's tempting to leave it on for a lot longer than 20 minutes, but it's not a good idea. Ice relieves pain and swelling because it constricts the blood vessels, which numbs the pain and reduces blood flow. Leave the ice on for too long however, and the blood vessels can get so constricted that more damage is caused, which in turn leads to even more swelling and inflammation.

q: What is the best way to care for an injury using ice and heat?
a:

Experts agree that RICE is the best way to care for a sports injury. RICE stands for Rest, Ice, Compression, and Elevation. In an ideal situation, you will ice the injury immediately after it happens for 15-20 minutes max. You should then follow 20 minutes with the injury on ice with 20 minutes off for the first 48 hours. After the first 48 hours, it's beneficial to apply ice to the injury for 15-20 minutes and then follow it immediately with a hot pack or by getting into a hot bath or tub. This causes fresh, oxygenated blood to flood into the cold area in the body's natural attempt to return balance to your circulatory system's overall temperature, which in turn speeds healing. This is where having multiple ice/hot packs can be extremely useful.

Sources

  1. Runner's World, Runner's World, Running Publication, Dec 01, 2009
  2. CWI Medical, CWI Medical, Clinical information,
  3. Runners Connect, Runners Connect, Running information,
  4. Competitor.com, Competitor, Sports & Fitness publication, Mar 14, 2011