10 Best Winter Boots Reviewed & Fully Compared
Footwear plays a huge role not only in proper running but in everyday use too. While it’s true that humans and other animals have been running on all manner of harsh terrain for thousands of years, we have since adopted these foot coverings as a way of protecting our feet from injury and exposure to extreme temperatures.
These boots are designed to be used in colder environments while keeping the wearer’s feet warm. In order to accomplish this, a delicate balance needs to be struck between providing decent durability and heat insulation without designing a product that is too bulky or heavy to perform well for normal use. The products listed here manage to find an acceptable compromise and provide a solid pair of winter boots as a result.
- Sorel 1964 Premium T
- Great Insulation & Waterproofing
- MuckBoots Hale
- Lightweight Design
- KEEN Revel III
- Great Traction
10 Best Winter Boots
Upon the first examination, these shoes resemble a saddle-style of footwear that has been out of fashion for quite some time. However, this strange style serves an important purpose, since it helps to provide fantastic insulation and waterproofing. Ultimately, this is a product that emphasizes function over form.
In order to provide the ultimate pair of winter boots, Sorel designed this product with many appealing features. These include a removable felt inner boot that allows for easy cleaning, a vulcanized rubber outsole that ensures terrific durability and water protection, and a warm and comfortable full-grain leather upper.
The primary materials used for these boots are rubber and leather. Due to their design, they can be comfortably worn with slim cut jeans tucked inside the boot shaft or with the standard boot cut option.
When comparing the cost of these winter boots to footwear that offers similar levels of resistance to harsh environments, these are priced at a very reasonable rate. A high-end pair of trail running shoes will usually cost a great deal more than these and only offer a fraction of the features available here.
- Amazing heat insulation and waterproofing
- High-quality construction materials
- Can be worn with slim cut or boot cut jeans
- Somewhat outdated style
- Heavier than ordinary trail shoes
MuckBoots come in a variety of color and style options but all varieties feature a relatively plain looking lower portion made from black rubber. However, the differences between styles can be seen on the lengthy upper shaft, with many interesting patterns and color schemes available to choose from.
Water protection is guaranteed due to the lower portion of these boots being made from rubber, which can come in handy when coming into contact with melting snow. Aside from this, the most notable feature is an extremely long shaft with a small calf loop to help wearers put these boots on.
As previously mentioned, rubber is used for the lower portion of the MuckBoots with what looks like neoprene on the upper shaft. Due to the excessive length of this upper shaft, some women with larger calves may have some difficulty fitting in these boots.
Some sizes and color options for these shoes come at a very reasonable discount. However, the most expensive option for these MuckBoots is on the higher end of the cost spectrum for similar products. Customers should expect to spend about as a much as they would for a high-end pair of boots.
- Lightweight feel due to design and construction materials
- Fantastic water protection from rubber and neoprene
- Wide variety of available styles and colors
- High upper shaft can cause problems for women with large calves
- Some styles and sizes are much more expensive than others
KEEN Revel III
The use of Roebuck leather gives these shoes a weathered and distinctive appearance that is sure to please any hard workers or outdoors enthusiasts. A few different color schemes are available as well, offering a small degree of versatility that helps to make these some seriously stylish boots.
The leather used for these boots provide excellent protection from water. A padded collar and dry membrane on the inside provide further waterproofing as well as heat insulation. On the underside, a full rubber outsole provides enough grip to handle snow and rain.
With rubber on the bottom and leather on top, these winter boots are made from some of the strongest viable footwear materials. In regards to sizing, the manufacturers suggest ordering a half size larger than usual due to the extra cushioning causing these boots to fit tighter than normal.
Being made from high-quality materials, it makes sense that these boots would come with a higher price. The cost is on par with a pair of very high-end trail running shoes but they are worth every penny. The exception is one or two sizes that seem to have highly inflated prices, most likely due to limited availability.
- Amazing build quality due to high-quality materials
- Rubber outsole provides superior grip on dangerous surfaces
- Good insulation from padded collar and dry internal membrane
- Smaller than average fit due to extra internal padding
- Highest cost, albeit not without justification
These are not stylish boots. When looking at the numerous straps and clasps the form the majority of this Baffin product, is is abundantly clear that fashion was not a primary concern when designing them.
The most impressive feature of these snow boots, aside from the fantastic stability offered by its heavy-duty straps and EVA midsole, is the seven layers of insulation. No other boot or trail shoe is going to offer this sort of heat protection, which is guaranteed for temperatures as low as below 40 degrees Fahrenheit.
The majority of these boot’s construction is derived from leather and textile, with EVA foam being used for the midsole and heavy-duty rubber for the outsole. Surprisingly, these winter boots aren’t nearly as heavy as their appearance would suggest.
The cost for an average pair of these Baffin winter boots is about the average for any other pair of high-end snowshoes. However, what gives this particular product an edge over its competitors is its unparalleled heat insulation.
- Seven layers of insulation provide warmth in extremely cold temperatures
- Excellent stability due to multiple straps and EVA midsole
- Lightweight despite bulky appearance
- Bulky and unfashionable style
- Limited color choices
The Original MuckBoots Arctic Sport Mid
These boots have a very simplistic style and are made of all black material. Due to the shape of this article of footwear, it more closely resembles a traditional rain boot and even features similar protection from moisture. Ultimately, this stark and utilitarian style is likely to polarize customers.
Moisture protection is the primary benefit to be gained from these MuckBoots with their neoprene and rubber construction. Aside from this, a stretch-fit internal thermal sleeve helps to provide much-needed warmth in snowy weather.
The primary materials used to make these shoes are neoprene on top, lightweight synthetic rubber on the middle, and heavy-duty rubber on the outsole. This careful distribution of weight results in a light feeling and shock-absorbent design sure to please most wearers.
The cost of these winter boots can wildly vary depending on what size is ordered. At its lowest, these MuckBoots are sold at an excellent value that beats most of its competitors. At its very highest, these shoes are still sold at a reasonable rate.
- Terrific moisture management due to neoprene and rubber materials
- Snug internal sleeve provides heat retention and insulation
- Lightweight design reduces calf strain
- Simplistic and polarizing design
- Lack of durable materials such as leather
Something that really helps these boots stand out from the back is the tuft of faux fur placed around the collar. In addition to the warming comfort offered by this soft insulator, the visual flair makes these winter boots look fancy.
Vibram material used for the outsole come with many benefits that are sure to be appreciated by serious trail runners and hikers. These boots are also waterproof and rated to handle cold temperatures as low as -20 Celsius.
With cow leather for the upper portion and wool for the interior, the selective use of authentic animal products is not wasted. Bits of synthetic material such as faux fur help to supplement the real thing, and a Vibram rubber outsole give these winter boots a strong underfoot foundation.
Since these are some fancy boots from a well-known brand, it can be understood why these Ugg boots cost so much. However, when looking at the actual product it becomes more difficult to justify the absurd price hike.
- Excellent water and weather protection
- Faux fur on the collar adds comfort and insulation
- Multiple color options available
- Fur elements may polarize some wearers
- Absurdly high price for little justification
All available models of these women’s boots feature a similar design and pattern on the outside with the changes mostly involving the color. What makes these boots stand out from any other winter wear is the faux fur lining which can be tufted out the top for a bit of extra flair.
Extra cushioning around the higher collar of these winter boots helps to avoid any discomfort that may otherwise be a result of this particular footwear style. On top of that, cement epoxies were used to bind these boots in a manner that guarantees high durability.
These boots are entirely made from synthetic materials. The lack of any authentic leather or wool may dissuade some purists from trying these boots on but those who are against the use of animal products will appreciate the design choices made by Kingshow for this product.
One fortunate benefit to these boots being made from all synthetics is that the price is competitively low. Because of the low cost of entry, even those on a budget will have a tough time finding excuses to stay indoors on a cold winter day.
- Faux fur lining ensures warmth and comfort
- Cement bonding agents provide terrific durability
- Conveniently low price tag
- Somewhat stilted style with limited differences between models
- Not made from any authentic animal products
Columbia Ice Maiden II
As a pair of boots meant for women, Columbia isn’t afraid to add some color to some of the available styles for the Ice Maiden II. The common options of blacks, browns, and shades in between are also accompanied by a few purple tones that customers are unlikely to find anywhere else.
The rubber outsole of these winter boots offer omnidirectional grip that help to maintain stable footing while running on unpredictable terrain. This works beautifully in conjunction with the lightweight Techlite midsole, which complements the outsole by providing comfort and energy return.
The waterproof construction of these Columbia boots is derived from a combination of real leather and synthetic textiles. Rubber used on the outsole provide stability and durability on the underfoot, resulting in a lightweight and cost-effective product.
Although the prices for different colors and sizes tend to vary, the price range still makes these boots very reasonable.
- Waterproof design with combination of leather and textile
- Multiple style options with color variety
- Reasonable price for included benefits
- Higher shaft may cause some discomfort
- May fit awkwardly with thick socks
These winter boots come in only one color: black. It’s a style that coordinates well with many other outfits but can also come across as rather simplistic and unappealing. Some fur-like material tufting out from the collar helps to make this product a bit more visually distinctive.
These are a bog-standard pair of boots with a few small features that provide additional convenience and comfort for colder temperatures. The higher shaft comes with additional laces for a sturdy fit and treading on the outsole allow for extra grip on certain surfaces.
As previously mentioned, these boots are entirely made from textiles and synthetics. No real animal products were used in the making of these winter boots; this will likely turn off many potential buyers but does come with the benefit of a lower price tag.
Without much being offered that gives these boots an edge over competing products, it’s a good thing they aren’t priced very high. However, they’re still just expensive enough to disqualify as an impulse buy for the majority of prospective customers.
- Sturdy fit maintained with high shaft and heavy laces
- Fur-like interior lining provides comfort and warmth
- Only one color option limits stylistic aspect
- No leather or wool used whatsoever
Sorel Joan Of Arctic Wedge Mid
These are far from the most fashionable boots available. It’s true that there are many different colors to choose from; however, the overall shape and design is unappealing in a way that borders on ugly.
These are a pair of boots with some serious mileage potential, thanks in part to their mostly leather construction. The durability of this waterproof material will likely outlast this boot’s insole, which is why it’s a good thing that Sorel made their insoles removable.
Probably the most appealing aspect of this product’s design is the fact that it uses high-quality, authentic, and waterproof leather for its upper. A rubber outsole provides additional durability as well as the kind of grip needed when navigating a snowy or icy path.
Being made from high-quality materials, it makes some sense that these Sorel winter boots come at such a high price. However, the fact that these shoes are extremely unappealing visually is likely to cause many to pass on these well-made foot coverings.
- Made from high quality materials
- Removable insole helps these boots last longer
- Unappealing design
- Very high price
The Criteria We Used to Find the Best Winter Boots
There are many different brands and manufacturers that have designed winter boots for sale. In order to weed out the best of the best, we’ve compared hundreds of available models to find the top 10 based on these specific factors:
While it is most important that a pair of boots function properly, it is also very important to many people that they look good as well. Shoes are a major fashion statement; after all, it’s important to put your best foot forward if you wish to impress your peers. This means that all boots on this list were evaluated based on how stylish they look and how many stylistic options they offer.
For the most part, all a winter boot needs to be considered a successful product is to completely cover the wearer’s foot and ankle while also keeping it warm. This section touches on these two design aspects but also takes into account any additional features added to each product, such as a more comfortable insole or a more efficient lacing system.
How much do these boots weigh? What are they made of? Do they offer sizes in both men’s and women’s? While factors like these can be considered in value judgments, these more specific questions considered in this section of the review are intended to clear up any ambiguities about the exact design of each boot.
Even the best pair of winter boots in the world will have a price limit that people will be willing to pay. This section ultimately compares the cost of each product to the quality of its construction and the features present in its design to determine whether or not it is priced reasonably. This section will also mention if any discounts are available.
Other Important Factors to Consider
Most customers reading this buying guide will have enough information from the criteria listed above to make an informed purchase. However, there are special cases in which certain individuals may require more information. For the sake of these people, here are some additional design factors worth their consideration:
Certain kinds of material used in the construction of boots can lead to an allergic reaction to certain predisposed individuals. If you have some sort of allergic sensitivity to particular textiles or insulating material, it would be wise to closely examine the materials used in each product to ensure they won’t lead to discomfort.
Sometimes, one pair of boots that costs more than another can actually provide a greater value. This can be due to the presence of an extended warranty, where the manufacturer offers to cover the costs of repair or replacement for a predetermined period of time after purchasing. While it probably shouldn’t make or break a purchasing decision, researching warranty options can help to pick one specific product over another.
Generally speaking, boots are designed to handle the widest possible array of terrain. However, it may be wise to research whether or not these boots work well on the specific form of terrain you are likely to encounter. For example, individuals in a snowy environment will want to find boots with excellent water and snow resistance, while hiking and trail running enthusiasts will want to find good off-roading boots.
Frequently Asked Questions
Q: When should I replace my boots?
A: There is no consistent time period where you should always replace your boots but as a general rule, you will have to replace them sooner if you don’t perform regular repairs on them. Some good indicators that it is time to replace a pair of boots are when layers start separating, treading becomes worn down, discomfort is felt while walking in them, or water begins leaking through.
Q: How do I clean my boots?
A: The first step when cleaning any kind of boot is to wipe away any dirt or grime with a soft cloth. For leather boots, the next step is to use a special leather conditioner to maintain the material’s quality. Other forms of boots may need to be treated with a non-silicone based waterproofing material periodically.
Q: Will my winter boots stretch?
A: Leather boots are known to stretch and can be done so in a controlled manner as part of the process of breaking them on. Boots made of rubber should not stretch; if they do, it will likely cause damage to them.
Q: How should I store my winter boots?
A: During the offseason, winter boots should be stored in an environment that isn’t too warm, is dry, and isn’t directly exposed to the sun. This is the best way to ensure they keep and can be used next winter. Failing to keep them in cool and dark environments can result in degradation of the material, and keeping them in a wet place can cause mildew.
Q: What is the most durable boot material?
A: In general, the most durable and long-lasting boots are made from some form of leather. The most common form is cowhide but a similar level of resilience can be found in boots made from buffalo leather as well. In order to ensure long-lasting durability, any leather-based footwear will need regular cleaning and conditioning.